|
 NetSword Discussion Forums
 Weapons Performance
 Katana vs. Broad Sword (Page 2)
|
 UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! This topic is 4 pages long: 1 2 3 4 |
next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Katana vs. Broad Sword |
|
Marshal Member |
posted 11-21-2004 11:17 PM
  
The Adept beats your Gray Mauser...and Fafhrd as well.  IP: 159.87.49.218 |
|
Max Member |
posted 11-22-2004 01:07 AM
quote: But I know the woman who will come when she's ready.  IP: 193.167.148.178 |
|
Megalophias Member |
posted 11-22-2004 11:36 AM
But everyone knows adepts can't handle the laughter of the Elder Gods.  IP: 198.162.22.24 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 11-22-2004 12:30 PM
Or the sound of my fart!
Oh no, that wasn't me. I swear it! [This message has been edited by Tak (edited 11-22-2004).] IP: 216.102.152.20 |
|
Marshal Member |
posted 11-24-2004 12:30 AM
Ohhhh, Tak...why'd ya have to go there? And me without any matches.  IP: 159.87.49.218 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 11-24-2004 11:13 AM
You do realize its murder if the explosion resulted from you lighting that match while I farted killed everyone in the forum? IP: 216.102.152.20 |
|
vince Member |
posted 12-12-2004 03:48 PM
from an actual combat perspective, it would depend on which weapon you were profficient in. i study kenjutsu,iaijutsu,german longsword, sword and shield and am learning buckler techniques. i personally would choose any of the above weapons(except sword and buckler as i'm not as capable there yet). japanese swords do have harder edges but are less flexible (hence they are less able to take abuse the only time you will see one sword slice through another is because of manufacturing defect or hollywood script) kenjutsu and german longsword techniques have some similarities but german longsword actually has more attacking options(not only the blade but the entire sword is a weapon, pluss the benefit of ringen am schwert should not be overlooked ).there is also a weight/balance difference. katanas tend to be no lighter and often heavier than their european cousins and their balance is usually closer to the tip.this means that they are not as quick. also, the more curve you have in a weapon the less deftness in defense you have.my longsword is lightning quick in fact my katana feels heavy in comparison-although it is the same weight.the longsword blade is eight inches longer giving you an advantage.a rapier or smallsword was a fine gentleman's dueling sword but utterly useless against a real sword in the hands of someone who knows how to use it(don't believe hollywood) in fact if anyone would care to hold a duel with me on an island in international waters- longsword to rapier- we could proove that point but don't forget to get your estate in order first .... to give final answer to this long reply. no martial art can truly be called superior to another. the victory lies in the skill of the warrior. you should check out some of the new books on medieval swordsmanship which are hitting the market.they might help to bring some perspective to this question. for a long time now, european swords have been unfairly( and inaccurately) portrayed as weak,dull,heavy,unwieldy weapons by the asian martial arts community,foil fencing(did i spell that wrong?)community,and hollywood. thankfully things are changing as the truth is becoming more accessable to the public. [This message has been edited by vince (edited 12-12-2004).] [This message has been edited by vince (edited 12-12-2004).] IP: 64.12.116.6 |
|
Marshal Member |
posted 12-12-2004 10:59 PM
The Bleak Shore. The Bleak Shore.
IP: 159.87.49.218 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 12-13-2004 01:30 AM
Gimme my gun, where is my friggin gun!? IP: 24.205.84.98 |
|
Weasel Unit Member |
posted 12-13-2004 09:19 AM
I tend to agree with TAK, but When i run out of bullets, or the enemy closes, ill reach for the broad sword, Even without elemental enhancements. Over on HK94 forums, we sometimes got caried away and had big drawn out SHTF (" Stuff Hit the Fan) scenarios. most popular was "WHAT IF ZOMBIES INVADED!?!?!?" scenario. In this topic, eveoryone discused what they would grab as they ran out the door to flee in terror of the zombies. If i had a choice of whatever i could muster, id say something .308, and a 2-handed sabre. IP: 158.158.240.231 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 12-13-2004 11:26 AM
Bayonets Weasel, BAYONETS Nothing like being up-close-n'-personal [This message has been edited by Tak (edited 12-13-2004).] IP: 216.102.152.20 |
|
Megalophias Member |
posted 12-13-2004 03:31 PM
Weird, Marshal, I never pictured you as a little man with a bulging head. IP: 24.71.189.200 |
|
Weasel Unit Member |
posted 12-13-2004 04:57 PM
Of course the gun would have a Bayo? did i forget to mention that? and whats this about little men with big heads? [This message has been edited by Weasel Unit (edited 12-13-2004).] IP: 158.158.240.231 |
|
Max Member |
posted 12-14-2004 12:22 AM
quote: The Bleak Shore. "Of the perils of boredom and of a great challenge and of a very long voyage. One cannot add to the account of these affairs by Ourph the Mingol." Death is (sometimes) a pale little man with a big head and a compelling voice. IP: 82.141.85.101 |
|
Marshal Member |
posted 12-15-2004 12:41 AM
quote: "All the world's a stage IP: 159.87.49.218 |
|
Andius Member |
posted 12-29-2004 12:05 PM
Instead of conventional bayonet, I would rather a trusty broadsword! When the fighting gets close and personal, my blade would go through the enemy and the man behind him! Uuhh, but then again, that aint possible There are acounts that many soldiers during the 1800's especially, they put their swords on the their rifles on bayonets. IP: 216.230.136.241 |
|
Andius Member |
posted 12-29-2004 12:08 PM
By the way, I would choose broadsword over the katana. Especially if I have shield with it! IP: 216.230.136.241 |
|
Marshall Member |
posted 02-28-2005 10:47 PM
quote:
IP: 83.146.12.195 |
|
jlhman21 Member |
posted 02-28-2005 10:53 PM
Wow, Tak's new friend has arrived.... ------------------ IP: 66.92.5.205 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 02-28-2005 11:45 PM
"Oooh, I'm jealous. Where can I find one with the cool velvet case and iron cross and everything?" Do you have $10,000? IP: 66.215.95.69 |
|
Marshall Member |
posted 02-28-2005 11:51 PM
Sure... Is it really that much? How many of them are there? [This message has been edited by Marshall (edited 03-01-2005).] IP: 83.146.12.195 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 03-01-2005 12:09 AM
Limited edition Mausers. I have one with original markings and scope, it cost me a fortune. I am not sure how much of these are left. The original swatisca were taken off after the war for obvious reasons, so its hard to find an original, re-engineered edition. You can maybe try the Yugoslav M48s. Those are excellent replicas of the original K98s, and some of them exist in military-new condition. They are also far cheaper than the original, around $299 - $500 as opposed to the collector's edition of some $6 - $10k. The M48, a beauty itself, but never as good as the original :P [This message has been edited by Tak (edited 03-01-2005).] IP: 66.215.95.69 |
|
Marshall Member |
posted 03-01-2005 12:37 AM
Oh, well, my friends dad has a 98k, complete with swastikas etc. (I guess you could say they were rubbed off, poorly and incompletely). I could just steal it from him I was really wondering about the case... is it an original that shipped with the gun, or was that a limited edition thing? or what? [This message has been edited by Marshall (edited 03-01-2005).] IP: 83.146.12.195 |
|
Tak Member |
posted 03-01-2005 08:20 AM
Limited collector edition only. The case itself would cost hundreds. IP: 66.215.95.69 |
|
Inuyasha Member |
posted 03-01-2005 08:08 PM
quote: Only $6? Well, who can argue with that price IP: 64.231.164.48 |
This topic is 4 pages long: 1 2 3 4 All times are CST, GMT-6 | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
  |
|
Contact Us |
NetSword
Netsword.com retains rights to all contained on this site. Writtem permission must be obtained for reprint.
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47a